Seems like J.K. Rowling got carried away!

by maryamnadeem on April 20, 2009

Finally after much waiting and longing, the last in the series, Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows hit the market, where thousands of Harry Potter fans rushed to get their copy of the last book. The kids were anxious to know how the famous series was going to end. There was a lot of fuss on how the story would reach its finish- would Harry Potter die or would Voldemort, the Dark Wizard kill him.

For those of you, who do not know who or what Harry Potter is about, it’s a magical and fantasy story about a boy who learns on his 11th birthday that he is a wizard and has been accepted in the Hogwarts School of witchcraft and wizardy, that is to say a new world opens for a boy who has been harassed by his aunt and uncle and his cousin who was given the responsibility of raising him under their roof, as a part of the family. Harry Potter deals with magic, dragons, wands and brooms, and to top it all with a cherry, the dark wizard is after the boy who lives a killing curse which was of course meant for him to be killed, in doing so his mother sacrificed herself and laid her protection around her little boy, the protection of love which repelled the Lord Voldemort from harming him.

harrypotter

That’s with the story, lets jump to the reactions of the readers who reached the ending, these are the words that can be described how the readers felt, disappointed, let down, unhappy, confused, irritated, and the list goes on and on and on. Take it from the fan from the Harry Potter, the whole essence of the story was lost, there were so many twists and turns and unanswered questions from the previous books that it was assumed not assumed but expected to have the answers in the last book. The result? More fresh questions rounded up on the corner with raised eye brows, what the hell did just happen to the story? It totally flipped over, nothing made sense, Harry all along had been protected by his friends and those people who liked him and felt for him, it seemed only fair that at the end he was to die along in killing Lord Voldemort. But that was not all- he lives a happily ever after?!!!

The book unfolds the story of the prophecy which was made about Harry or the choosen one and Lord Voldemort, that neither lives while the other survives. Prophecy meant that neither would live while the other would survive, simple words one of them had to die to let the other die, which should have been as it is, Harry dying and sacrificing himself in order to erase and wipe out the Dark Lord once and for all. But ironically it does not happen.

Some of the readers might think that his character has suffered a lot, yes in a lot of ways he has, but that did not meant there had to be a happily ever after, Rowling should have made Harry’s character strong enough to give away his life for all the lives Voldemort took, that seems reasonable and makes more sense to the story- this would have made the story look more real and meaningful, but sadly that was not all, he succeeds in killing Voldemort and moves on to live his happy life, now that looks like a story out of a fairy tale, let’s rewind and check again, the whole story is based on fantasy which almost seems real to the reader who reads and indulges into it, but fantasy is not always a happy ever after, ever afters are fairy tales, there’s a slight distinction in between the two. Fantasy can be made a little harsh in order to give it a touch of reality and in Harry Potter, the character should have sacrificed himself in killing the Dark Wizard, which was not it, the story ended on such a bad note that the whole essence, the whole point of the whole series was lost and hence life isn’t and shouldn’t always be told as a happily ever after but fantasy can have a touch of reality in it, resulting in more sense and the more “real” side to the story.

{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }

dc April 20, 2009 at 8:46 pm

Actually Maryam, I really think that you are too late to write this post :) . But yes I agree with you on many points, story didn’t ended the way everyone expected. Story makes the sense before Harry was going to face voldemort, I still remember that my heart was beating hard when I was reading the lines in which Harry was going to going to fight Voldy, but hell everything changed after that, story become totally stupid, in the six books, we read that Lord Voldy was so powerful and all that, and from that point, he is presented as a weak person. And such a short epilogue. And the worst happened when JK Rowling announced that Dumbledore was a gay :/

However, I still feel happy that Harry survived and JK finally made Snape a hero.

Maddie April 20, 2009 at 9:16 pm

nice effort…it cud’ve carried much more insight about other things that J.K got carried away with too..like the love stories going on and the part of “nineteen years later”…how she never answers questions that were hanging from the first part…and the fact that she made Ted Lupin metamorphically resemble Harry by killing off Lupin and Tonks, was really called for??

Batool April 22, 2009 at 1:14 pm

2 thumbs up mayyam(Y)(Y)

mustajab April 30, 2009 at 1:44 pm

nice peice of work…

nanana May 27, 2009 at 9:17 pm

Sorry, I have to disagree. Not everyone was stuck on having Harry killed like you seem to be. I personally liked the way things turned out, imagine how people would react if Harry would die?!?! J.K. was just trying to compromise. And the prophecy still turned out true. Voldemort does die. The horcruxes were what was keeping him alive. And Harry being a Horcrux makes a lot of sense considering how the killing curse pretty much rebounded. Also the Deathly Hollows made him master over death which is why he couldn’t officially die. So that kind of evens things out. I thought J.K. did a really good job with the last book and how she interconnected things from the first books. Her books were extremely detailed and the fact that she had stuff planned out from book to book amazes me. I’m just saying that not everyone thinks that Harry has to die to make the last book good. I do agree that the “nineteen years later” is a little to “happy” as you call it, but overall the 7th book is superb.

Chloe June 18, 2009 at 4:22 pm

I’m sorry, but I don’t seem to be agreeing.

First, you say that Harry Potter and J. K. Rowling suck, just because of the ending of the last book. Really?

And you say that it would be better if Harry was strong enough to die. He was! It was his intention to die! But the horcrux saved him.

And you say there’s a happily ever after…well I completely disagree. A lot of his friends and family died in the war. That’s not too happy.

Then you say that the epilogue was too happy. Well, the epilogue showcased one part of his life. One happy part. Wouldn’t it be a happy day to see your children go off to a school that you used to call home? Really.

You went on and on about that fantasy and “touch of reality.” Reread the books if you don’t think they have a “touch of reality.”

So

Amy April 23, 2010 at 3:30 pm

I’m sorry, but I don’t seem to be agreeing.

First, you say that Harry Potter and J. K. Rowling suck, just because of the ending of the last book. Really?

And you say that it would be better if Harry was strong enough to die. He was! It was his intention to die! But the horcrux saved him.

And you say there’s a happily ever after…well I completely disagree. A lot of his friends and family died in the war. That’s not too happy.

Then you say that the epilogue was too happy. Well, the epilogue showcased one part of his life. One happy part. Wouldn’t it be a happy day to see your children go off to a school that you used to call home? Really.

You went on and on about that fantasy and “touch of reality.” Reread the books if you don’t think they have a “touch of reality.”

So

Bruce May 19, 2010 at 11:06 pm

I’m sorry, but I don’t seem to be agreeing.

First, you say that Harry Potter and J. K. Rowling suck, just because of the ending of the last book. Really?

And you say that it would be better if Harry was strong enough to die. He was! It was his intention to die! But the horcrux saved him.

And you say there’s a happily ever after…well I completely disagree. A lot of his friends and family died in the war. That’s not too happy.

Then you say that the epilogue was too happy. Well, the epilogue showcased one part of his life. One happy part. Wouldn’t it be a happy day to see your children go off to a school that you used to call home? Really.

You went on and on about that fantasy and “touch of reality.” Reread the books if you don’t think they have a “touch of reality.”

So

Bruce May 22, 2010 at 7:51 am

Sorry, I have to disagree. Not everyone was stuck on having Harry killed like you seem to be. I personally liked the way things turned out, imagine how people would react if Harry would die?!?! J.K. was just trying to compromise. And the prophecy still turned out true. Voldemort does die. The horcruxes were what was keeping him alive. And Harry being a Horcrux makes a lot of sense considering how the killing curse pretty much rebounded. Also the Deathly Hollows made him master over death which is why he couldn’t officially die. So that kind of evens things out. I thought J.K. did a really good job with the last book and how she interconnected things from the first books. Her books were extremely detailed and the fact that she had stuff planned out from book to book amazes me. I’m just saying that not everyone thinks that Harry has to die to make the last book good. I do agree that the “nineteen years later” is a little to “happy” as you call it, but overall the 7th book is superb.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: